{"id":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","slug":"scientific-critical-thinking","publicId":"591b88d2-101c-4b43-b76b-8bf290c73add","name":"scientific-critical-thinking","description":"Evaluates scientific claims and evidence quality. Applies to experimental design validity, biases and confounders, statistical interpretation, evidence grading frameworks (GRADE, Cochrane Risk of Bias), and teaching critical analysis. Supports evidence appraisal and identifying flaws; formal peer review writing belongs to peer-review.","version":"1.5","author":"k-dense-ai","license":"MIT license","compatibility":"Analytical guidance needs no network. Optional figures via the scientific-schematics skill require OPENROUTER_API_KEY and outbound API access to OpenRouter.","status":"completed","overallGrade":"B","scannerVersion":11,"fileCount":9,"hasSkillMd":true,"hasScripts":false,"hasReferences":true,"hasEvals":false,"hasAssets":false,"sourceType":"github","sourceUrl":"https://github.com/k-dense-ai/scientific-agent-skills/tree/main/skills/scientific-critical-thinking","createdAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:58.472Z","completedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:58.470Z","visibility":"public","publishedAt":"2026-09-10T21:05:21.336Z","category":"","frameworks":[],"badgeStatus":"conditional","downloadCount":0,"verdictRationale":{"summary":"Skill has warnings: 1 warning in security or structure checks.","verdict":"warn","scanners":[{"source":"vettd","weight":1,"verdict":"warn"},{"source":"cisco","weight":0.8,"verdict":"pass"}],"consensus":"warn","warnTriggers":["References external URL — review for indirect prompt injection risk"],"policyVersion":"consensus-v1","hardFailTriggers":[]},"verdictPolicyVersion":"consensus-v1","skillId":"cmtw0np9fb9vnad07kic67o1q","findings":[{"id":"cmuxihly50lhwad07vt1muk5g","source":"vettd","category":"security","label":"References external URL — review for indirect prompt injection risk","detail":"External URL(s) detected in SKILL.md — referenced content can change after audit","severity":"medium","ruleId":"VTD-0088","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"42638a8b7e9fc5df27449992eaebc724","filepath":"SKILL.md"}],"scannerRuns":[{"source":"cisco","status":"success","verdict":null,"grade":"A","findingCount":0,"criticalCount":0,"highCount":0},{"source":"vettd","status":"success","verdict":null,"grade":"B","findingCount":1,"criticalCount":0,"highCount":0}],"user":{"name":"Kris Mondlane","image":"https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/u/237055?v=4"},"repository":{"owner":"k-dense-ai","name":"scientific-agent-skills"},"freshness":{"status":"verified_unchanged","reason":null,"retryable":false,"renamedTo":null,"lastCheckedAt":"2026-10-22T00:06:06.947Z","lastVerifiedAt":"2026-10-22T00:06:06.947Z","lastChangeDetectedAt":"2026-10-09T08:55:29.255Z","scannedHash":"a658236e69d700577a095bccf8d87fe7391bd22d","latestUpstreamHash":"a658236e69d700577a095bccf8d87fe7391bd22d","nextCheckDueAt":"2026-10-23T00:37:35.119Z"},"signalCategories":[{"category":"safety","label":"Safety","form":"graded","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"reliability","label":"Reliability & Quality","form":"graded","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"performance","label":"Performance","form":"measured","verdict":{"form":"measured","magnitudes":[{"ruleId":"performance/static-context-tokens","label":"Static context tokens","value":2506,"unit":null,"method":"tiktoken/cl100k_base/skill-md-body"}]},"rows":[{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxihmjp0lktad07po68sott","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"performance","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"performance/static-context-tokens","severity":null,"label":"Static context tokens","detail":null,"valueNum":2506,"valueText":null,"unit":null,"method":"tiktoken/cl100k_base/skill-md-body","derivation":null,"confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxihp3c0lzrad07v8k93v36","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"performance","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"performance/progressive-disclosure","severity":null,"label":"Progressive disclosure","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"present","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null}]},{"category":"cost","label":"Cost","form":"measured","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"compatibility","label":"Compatibility","form":"unjudged","verdict":{"form":"unjudged"},"rows":[{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxihmmv0llhad07slhl101q","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-environment-assumptions","severity":null,"label":"Declared environment assumptions","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"Analytical guidance needs no network. Optional figures via the scientific-schematics skill require OPENROUTER_API_KEY and outbound API access to OpenRouter.","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxihnme0lnvad07ylmzo1uz","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"declared_tool","relatedId":"Edit","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-required-tools","severity":null,"label":"Declared required tool","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"Edit","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxihnxp0lqsad074cgh88qm","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"declared_tool","relatedId":"Write","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-required-tools","severity":null,"label":"Declared required tool","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"Write","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxihnsm0lpmad073027zxy8","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"declared_tool","relatedId":"Read","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-required-tools","severity":null,"label":"Declared required tool","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"Read","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmuxiho8w0ltfad07tc3gdqjp","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmuxihly50lhvad077okcksbk","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-name","severity":null,"label":"Declared skill name","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"scientific-critical-thinking","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-07T02:51:49.000Z","payload":null}]},{"category":"sentiment","label":"Popularity","form":"unjudged","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"characteristics","label":"Characteristics","form":"unjudged","verdict":null,"rows":[]}],"signalCount":27,"publisherSupplied":["name","description","author","version","license"]}