{"id":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","slug":"brainstorming","publicId":"2783a765-f4ca-483a-add1-fb41ce11ebc4","name":"brainstorming","description":"You MUST use this before any creative work - creating features, building components, adding functionality, modifying behavior, or planning anything new, in software or out of it (a talk, a business, a renovation).","version":"","author":"obra","license":"MIT","compatibility":"","status":"completed","overallGrade":"F","scannerVersion":11,"fileCount":8,"hasSkillMd":true,"hasScripts":true,"hasReferences":false,"hasEvals":false,"hasAssets":false,"sourceType":"github","sourceUrl":"https://github.com/obra/superpowers/tree/main/skills/brainstorming","createdAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.952Z","completedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.949Z","visibility":"public","publishedAt":"2026-08-20T18:35:07.937Z","category":"","frameworks":[],"badgeStatus":"flagged","downloadCount":0,"verdictRationale":{"summary":"Skill failed: 2 hard fails in security or structure checks.","verdict":"fail","scanners":[{"source":"vettd","weight":1,"verdict":"fail"},{"source":"cisco","weight":0.8,"verdict":"fail"}],"consensus":"fail","warnTriggers":[],"policyVersion":"consensus-v1","hardFailTriggers":["Shell execution without sandboxing","High-entropy value — potential hardcoded secret"]},"verdictPolicyVersion":"consensus-v1","skillId":"cmt1v1mhm7v6vad09u8w2a8i5","findings":[{"id":"cmviq0azl1jhfad07wj6ft55j","source":"vettd","category":"security","label":"High-entropy value — potential hardcoded secret","detail":"Detected in scripts/start-server.sh:121 — `BRAINSTORM_TOKEN_FILE = [REDACTED]`","severity":"critical","ruleId":"VTD-0003","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"93b735be989e1c63f11dcd481ff2d21a","filepath":"scripts/start-server.sh"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhqad07fkfgrtha","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js child_process module usage for shell command execution","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:537 — Pattern detected: require('child_process')","severity":"critical","ruleId":"COMMAND_INJECTION_JS_CHILD_PROCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"a28c4d7b1b3442b741d9a1d56d6e5553","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azl1jhead07clnxf5ld","source":"vettd","category":"security","label":"Shell execution without sandboxing","detail":"Detected in scripts/server.cjs:537 — `const cp = require('child_process');`","severity":"critical","ruleId":"VTD-0018","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":"negligent","chainId":null,"fingerprint":"e9bff665d2bcf7d54e6c962270d3d519","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhjad07e6mrsrfc","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:138 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhkad07u30lq4d1","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:202 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhlad07wq05ry75","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:203 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhmad076zly291r","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:217 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhnad0776xrhnee","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:409 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhoad07aq4y0b68","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:433 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhpad07roz8j1dp","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:515 — Pattern detected: fs.appendFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhrad078perzcx1","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:620 — Pattern detected: fs.writeFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhsad0751z41d5a","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:673 — Pattern detected: fs.writeFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhtad073t0phj78","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:676 — Pattern detected: fs.writeFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhuad076zln6gab","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:688 — Pattern detected: fs.writeFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azl1jhhad07fnfammke","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Node.js filesystem access candidate for sensitive-flow correlation","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:93 — Pattern detected: fs.readFileSync(","severity":"low","ruleId":"DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"eb2bd165918450b3363520f9473e7e4d","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azm1jhiad07a1si16r2","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Script contacts a destination the documentation never mentions","detail":"scripts/server.cjs:106 — Script contacts or configures 'primeradiant.com' but the skill documentation never visibly mentions it. Undocumented network destinations can indicate behaviour the manifest and description do not disclose.","severity":"low","ruleId":"UNDECLARED_NETWORK_DESTINATION","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"f22a3bd191758aaee1a5fef086f01c29","filepath":"scripts/server.cjs"},{"id":"cmviq0azl1jhgad07bjo3bhyw","source":"cisco","category":"security","label":"Skill does not specify a license","detail":"SKILL.md — Skill manifest does not include a 'license' field. Specifying a license helps users understand usage terms.","severity":"info","ruleId":"MANIFEST_MISSING_LICENSE","owaspLlmCategory":null,"intent":null,"chainId":null,"fingerprint":"592f7ac7731768f0fd0bba83f30850f9","filepath":"SKILL.md"}],"scannerRuns":[{"source":"cisco","status":"success","verdict":null,"grade":"F","findingCount":15,"criticalCount":1,"highCount":1},{"source":"vettd","status":"success","verdict":null,"grade":"F","findingCount":2,"criticalCount":2,"highCount":2}],"user":{"name":"Justin Pacella","image":"https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/u/97124458?v=4"},"repository":{"owner":"obra","name":"superpowers"},"freshness":{"status":"verified_unchanged","reason":null,"retryable":false,"renamedTo":null,"lastCheckedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:38.289Z","lastVerifiedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:38.289Z","lastChangeDetectedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:06.833Z","scannedHash":"3d8a23691e919f5acfd31d45f76bdc168d24ca1b","latestUpstreamHash":"3d8a23691e919f5acfd31d45f76bdc168d24ca1b","nextCheckDueAt":"2026-10-22T20:42:41.610Z"},"signalCategories":[{"category":"safety","label":"Safety","form":"graded","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"reliability","label":"Reliability & Quality","form":"graded","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"performance","label":"Performance","form":"measured","verdict":{"form":"measured","magnitudes":[{"ruleId":"performance/static-context-tokens","label":"Static context tokens","value":3122,"unit":null,"method":"tiktoken/cl100k_base/skill-md-body"}]},"rows":[{"origin":"signal","id":"cmviq0b321ji1ad072seg9y6h","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"performance","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"performance/static-context-tokens","severity":null,"label":"Static context tokens","detail":null,"valueNum":3122,"valueText":null,"unit":null,"method":"tiktoken/cl100k_base/skill-md-body","derivation":null,"confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmviq0b6a1jixad07178zvags","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"performance","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"performance/progressive-disclosure","severity":null,"label":"Progressive disclosure","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"present","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.000Z","payload":null}]},{"category":"cost","label":"Cost","form":"measured","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"compatibility","label":"Compatibility","form":"unjudged","verdict":{"form":"unjudged"},"rows":[{"origin":"signal","id":"cmviq0b3a1ji3ad07rvxb69va","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-environment-assumptions","severity":null,"label":"Declared environment assumptions","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmviq0b4h1jifad07olj3ny6z","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/declared-name","severity":null,"label":"Declared skill name","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"brainstorming","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmviq0b6j1jizad072lk14jgr","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/cli-help","severity":null,"label":"CLI help","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"absent","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.000Z","payload":null},{"origin":"signal","id":"cmviq0b6p1jj1ad07w9ocarrh","subjectType":"skill_audit","subjectId":"cmviq0azl1jhdad07azm3qi3w","relatedType":"","relatedId":"","dataCategory":"compatibility","sourceClass":"scan","source":"vettd","ruleId":"compatibility/structured-output","severity":null,"label":"Structured output","detail":null,"valueNum":null,"valueText":"present","unit":null,"method":null,"derivation":"read","confidence":null,"sampleSize":null,"synthetic":false,"firstParty":true,"observedAt":"2026-10-21T23:05:37.000Z","payload":null}]},{"category":"sentiment","label":"Popularity","form":"unjudged","verdict":null,"rows":[]},{"category":"characteristics","label":"Characteristics","form":"unjudged","verdict":null,"rows":[]}],"signalCount":42,"publisherSupplied":["name","description","author","version","license"]}